This is the forum archive of Homey. For more information about Homey, visit the Official Homey website.

The Homey Community has been moved to https://community.athom.com.

This forum is now read-only for archive purposes.

Slide make your existing curtains smart (kickstarter)

1246

Comments

  • skandshus said:
    Does anybody know when this will be able to buy in the “shops”??
    After the KS delivery's and preorders :) But as you can read in the update i posted above they will come with a roadmap/dates after 3 weeks 
  • skandshus said:
    Does anybody know when this will be able to buy in the “shops”??
    After the KS delivery's and preorders :) But as you can read in the update i posted above they will come with a roadmap/dates after 3 weeks 


    Allright. Thank you.. guess I’ll have to wait then.. this is gonna cost me :( I had NO use for it when Kickstarter campaign started.. since them I’ve invested a lot in IOT. So I’ll just have to suck it up and pay the full price for 40 units..:)
    im glad they came through on The project.. Good Luck to those people..:)
  • skandshus said:
    skandshus said:
    Does anybody know when this will be able to buy in the “shops”??
    After the KS delivery's and preorders :) But as you can read in the update i posted above they will come with a roadmap/dates after 3 weeks 


    Allright. Thank you.. guess I’ll have to wait then.. this is gonna cost me :( I had NO use for it when Kickstarter campaign started.. since them I’ve invested a lot in IOT. So I’ll just have to suck it up and pay the full price for 40 units..:)
    im glad they came through on The project.. Good Luck to those people..:)
    40 units? How big is your house/office? <span>:open_mouth:</span>
  • jorden said:
    skandshus said:
    skandshus said:
    Does anybody know when this will be able to buy in the “shops”??
    After the KS delivery's and preorders :) But as you can read in the update i posted above they will come with a roadmap/dates after 3 weeks 


    Allright. Thank you.. guess I’ll have to wait then.. this is gonna cost me :( I had NO use for it when Kickstarter campaign started.. since them I’ve invested a lot in IOT. So I’ll just have to suck it up and pay the full price for 40 units..:)
    im glad they came through on The project.. Good Luck to those people..:)
    40 units? How big is your house/office? <span>:open_mouth:</span>


    Only 180 m3.. but the latest owner had an extra living room added with 10 windows and the ceiling is made of glass windows (8).. so that took it self eats 18:(
    • "There's a weird, subtle ticking noise, also when you don't use it" 
    It would be good to know how 'subtle' this is and if they are going to do something about it. From their comments it doesn't feel like they have a solution for it yet.
  • lubbertkramerlubbertkramer Member
    edited January 2018
    • "There's a weird, subtle ticking noise, also when you don't use it" 
    It would be good to know how 'subtle' this is and if they are going to do something about it. From their comments it doesn't feel like they have a solution for it yet.
    If you quote the update please also read the entire update because the answer is below the problems they found during the beta round. They said when the next update will come so that can have an answer to solve it :)

    Also is the opposite that open/close is a lack of noise :) If you read @jorden his statement couple posts up:

    Quote @jorden:
    jorden said:

    My impressions so far:
    - Very good app, one thing is kinda unclear during setup (I have reported that to IIM)
    - Installation will probably not be < 5 minutes, but I think within 15 minutes should be possible. I do not have an installation manual yet so I had to figure it all out myself when I had to redo the installation, but it was 90% clear and 10% I guessed correctly. Please mind that I have 2 left hands when it comes to stuff like this :)
    - Slide is a bit bigger than expected, but I think that the beta version I have is different than the final product.
    - I can fully hide Slide behind my curtains without a problem. Actually, it's quite hard to show Slide to people because I placed the curtains "over" it. It is 0% visible if you look at my curtains, whether they are opened or closed.
    - Moving the curtains by hand is still possible and not a problem at all. I haven't tested yet how long it takes before Slide sees that they are open.
    - I was shocked by the lack of noise! I was expecting a lot more noise when opening/closing, but it is a really low level of "smooth" noise. Not annoying at all, I can hear it from meters away if everything in my house is quiet but it often happens that Slide has closed or opened while I was home without me noticing.
    - The curtains move really smooth, not with shocks/pulls but just one smooth move. Fully opened or closed they hang beautiful, better than when I do it by hand.
    - I also hear the ticking described in the mail. It's only noticable when you sit right next to it, and happens at random times. I didn't think of this until they mentioned it in the mail.  Will report that :)

    I am really looking forward to receiving Slides for my other 3 curtains. I open and close 2 of them by hand every day, and now that Slide does the other one I am really getting annoyed by doing the other 2 by hand....

    The Homey app is also close to done. I am only struggling to make the cards that Homey produces automaticly (Condition: "Curtains are open/closed", Action: "Open/Close curtain") because nobody seems to be able to tell me which function/capability Homey is using for that... but I'm sure Bas will tell me once I bug him again.

    The "mobile" card in Homey  works though, using a "dimmer" slide to be able to percentually open/close the curtains using the device or using the flow action card. I need the app before summer's here, because then I usually have my windows open and when the windows are open it is not possible to close the curtains. Going to use a doorsensor for that.


    Answer Slide from the same update where you quote the problem:

    1. Servo ticking

    Those of you who've regularly read our updates will know that the servo, which is the heart of our spool-coupling mechanism, has been probably the biggest pain-in-the-ass in building Slide. We've gone through dozens of different brands and types. When we started the beta test, we thought we had resolve the mechanical issues. And although the servo does what it should do, even the slightest misalignment will cause it to make an audible, ticking noise both directly after a curtain movement and at random times. Even though the servo now actually works, this is still an issue most testers identified as unacceptable. After a year of engineering with a servo, this is a clear line and Kaj is now working with our engineers on a servo-less coupling mechanism.

  • PaulKesselsPaulKessels Member
    edited January 2018
    I obviously have read the whole thread. But the answer they gave isn't really an answer, but more of a problem statement which in its nature is not very promising. It has been a pain in the ass, and they apparently have had many issues with it. So why would they suddenly be able to solve it after years of engineering? 

    My question is towards backers that have received the slide. It would be good to get some feedback or video recording of the problem. Also, they might know more about the status of this problem.

    Nailing this problem might make the difference for me and others between backing it or spending a few more bucks on an alternative that works (with possibly more noisy when operating the curtains; which personally is not really an issue for 10-20 seconds per day).
  • lubbertkramerlubbertkramer Member
    edited January 2018
    I obviously have read the whole thread. But the answer they gave isn't really an answer, but more of a problem statement which in its nature is not very promising. It has been a pain in the ass, and they apparently have had many issues with it. So why would they suddenly be able to solve it after years of engineering? 

    My question is towards backers that have received the slide. It would be good to get some feedback or video recording of the problem. Also, they might know more about the status of this problem.

    Nailing this problem might make the difference for me and others between backing it or spending a few more bucks on an alternative that works (with possibly more noisy when operating the curtains; which personally is not really an issue for 10-20 seconds per day).
    Then you know that there will be a new update in two weeks witch will probably give more answers after their research / tests on the servo-less coupling mechanism. Give them some time and credits that they openly address this problem. If you read up then you can see they update as promised every time and give lots of details :)

    @jorden already posted his expierence and @julian also has recieved a beta unit, for as far as i know there are no more Homey users in the beta test at this moment but maybe they can let us know how they expierence it
  • PaulKesselsPaulKessels Member
    edited January 2018
    Yes, don't get me wrong. I love the concept and really hope they get it to work and fix it. Also their updates and communication with lots of details is awesome! :)

    But nothing beats first hand user experience, so it would be great indeed to keep updates on experiences from users and copies of communication from Slide coming (esp. the updates only backers receive).

  • Yes, don't get me wrong. I love the concept and really hope they get it to work and fix it. Also their updates and communication with lots of details is awesome! :)

    But nothing beats first hand user experience, so it would be great indeed to keep updates on experiences from users and copies of communication from Slide coming (esp. the updates only backers receive).

    That's why i post them :) But good to hear, but i think its best to wait until the new update that will come Monday February 5th and hopefully they have come up with a solution for the noise! February 3th my new home get his curtains (finally) so i hope they will also bring good some news with the new roadmap/timeline for delivery so i can get my hands on my 5 KS units :)
  • @PaulKessels
    In my case I have not heard the ticking noise they mentioned, so it will be hard to post a video of that. I have probably a good unit, because apart from some connectivity issues which are known and they are working on it works really good. Again, the lack of noise is really amazing. The main noise comes from the moving runners themself, so I can hardly blame Slide for that  :)
  • That's great to read!
  • Julian said:
    @PaulKessels
    In my case I have not heard the ticking noise they mentioned, so it will be hard to post a video of that. I have probably a good unit, because apart from some connectivity issues which are known and they are working on it works really good. Again, the lack of noise is really amazing. The main noise comes from the moving runners themself, so I can hardly blame Slide for that  :)
    The problem only seems to occur if your Slide unit is not placed 100% "straight" ("waterpas" in Dutch).

    If there is any noise around (a tv that is on, for example) you won't hear the ticking. I didn't hear the ticking this week.
  • The first version of this app for Slide-support in Homey is now done. I have submitted it for approval to the app store.

    It is quite basic but works really well:
    - Installation, the app searches for all Slide devices in your current network
    - The added devices can be controlled by a "slider", to open and close as far as you want it.
    - There is a trigger card that has the #level of how far it is opened/closed (0.00 for fully open, 1.00 for fully closed)
    - There is an action card where you can set the position
    - There is an action card for "immediate stop"
    - I poll the device(s) every 15 seconds so if you open by hand or using the smartphone app, it will also be detected. Shorter than 15 seconds didn't work too well for me since it then reports in "steps" (I tried with 3 seconds, then you get a trigger every 3 seconds with 0.03, 0.10, 0.15, 0.21 etc)
  • jorden said:
    The first version of this app for Slide-support in Homey is now done. I have submitted it for approval to the app store.

    It is quite basic but works really well:
    - Installation, the app searches for all Slide devices in your current network
    - The added devices can be controlled by a "slider", to open and close as far as you want it.
    - There is a trigger card that has the #level of how far it is opened/closed (0.00 for fully open, 1.00 for fully closed)
    - There is an action card where you can set the position
    - There is an action card for "immediate stop"
    - I poll the device(s) every 15 seconds so if you open by hand or using the smartphone app, it will also be detected. Shorter than 15 seconds didn't work too well for me since it then reports in "steps" (I tried with 3 seconds, then you get a trigger every 3 seconds with 0.03, 0.10, 0.15, 0.21 etc)
    Great! Hope my 5 units will ship fast so i can place them in my home, hopefully the next update will give a timeline for delivery.

    Next saturday our curtains will be placed, you said the space between the rail/wall was to close should 10cm be enough? 
  • jorden said:
    The first version of this app for Slide-support in Homey is now done. I have submitted it for approval to the app store.

    It is quite basic but works really well:
    - Installation, the app searches for all Slide devices in your current network
    - The added devices can be controlled by a "slider", to open and close as far as you want it.
    - There is a trigger card that has the #level of how far it is opened/closed (0.00 for fully open, 1.00 for fully closed)
    - There is an action card where you can set the position
    - There is an action card for "immediate stop"
    - I poll the device(s) every 15 seconds so if you open by hand or using the smartphone app, it will also be detected. Shorter than 15 seconds didn't work too well for me since it then reports in "steps" (I tried with 3 seconds, then you get a trigger every 3 seconds with 0.03, 0.10, 0.15, 0.21 etc)
    Great! Hope my 5 units will ship fast so i can place them in my home, hopefully the next update will give a timeline for delivery.

    Next saturday our curtains will be placed, you said the space between the rail/wall was to close should 10cm be enough? 
    10 cm is plenty! I think the minimum is 5cm.
  • @jorden
    Great, installed it immediately!

    But my Slide cannot be connected to Homey, when trying to add the wheel keeps spinning. I restarted both Homey and Slide and Slide does respond to its own app. 

    Please let me know what else I can try? 
  • jorden said:

    Next saturday our curtains will be placed, you said the space between the rail/wall was to close should 10cm be enough? 
    10 cm is plenty! I think the minimum is 5cm.
    Well, do not forget that you also need some room at the bottom for the curtains, that is usually more than at the top, so if the distance is the same to the wall top and bottom you should take about 8-10cm from the wall anyway. Otherwise the curtains may run against the wall at the bottom. 
  • Julian said:
    @jorden
    Great, installed it immediately!

    But my Slide cannot be connected to Homey, when trying to add the wheel keeps spinning. I restarted both Homey and Slide and Slide does respond to its own app. 

    Please let me know what else I can try? 
    Hmmm that's odd! Is your Slide in the same (Wifi) network as your Homey?
  • Yes it is. Only one WiFi network here.
  • @PaulKessels the answer on your serve question in the new update :) 

    Posted by Innovation in Motion (Creator)
    Backer3x For backers only

    Hey everyone!  

    It’s another Monday, which means this is Kaj and Thijs with the latest update on Slide. I’m genuinely excited about this one, because we’ve had three good weeks that we’ll brief you on. We also went through a planning meeting with our production partners to put together a timeline from now till the moment Slide lands on your doorstep. Let’s go!

    In our last update we shared some of the initial feedback from the first beta test round. Based on that, we identified three key to-do’s: (1) malfunctioning servo (hardware), (2) connectivity issues (software) and (3) curtain system compatibility. I’ll go through the progress/status on each of these below.  

    1. Servo is out!  

    As mentioned previously, the servo has always been a troublemaker. We know these updates are already quite detailed (and we think that’s generally appreciated) – but they still just cover a fraction of the things we do. One of those things is that Kaj had already been working on a servo-less design in the evening hours for a few months. We didn’t share it as we didn’t think we would go that way – but based on the beta test, we decided to accelerate that R&D effort last month.  

    So here’s the good news – we have a working proof of concept. Instead of a servo, we ‘copy’ the primary acceleration from the DC motor onto a secondary axis (using a slip clutch) which acts as a coupling. The result is full elimination of the servo in what Jesper adequately dubbed ‘an excellent piece of engineering porn’. Importantly, the servo was the last internal problem we could not get right. The next step is to iterate on this proof of concept and test it at length, but we are quite confident about this because compared to the servo, this coupling is significantly simpler. For those who want to know more on the technical details, I’ll shoot a video with Kaj for the next update where he’ll explain it in more detail.  

    2. Software: Connectivity issues (& Homey App) 

    We’ve narrowed down the rather broad multicast connectivity issue into two separate bugs, one relating to DTIM/Beacon interval changes and the other to a hostname addressing issue. The first issue, which caused Slide to become fully unresponsive and require a power reset, is resolved. We will roll out an OTA firmware update later this week to fix the issue. The update will also include an optimized calibration algorithm. We’re still working on the second connectivity bug, which requires you to re-add Slide to the Slide App. 

    For those Homey-powered beta-testers who missed it: Jorden has done some awesome work in releasing the first version of the Homey App for Slide. Here’s to many more community integrations in the future :-) 

    3. Curtain system compatibility 

    Over the past weeks we’ve thought a lot about how to transform Slide from a solution that works with many curtain systems to one that works with virtually all of them. We have made several iterations of the Slide Mount design, which now fits into Slide itself (recessed). But a large part of that thinking was about how to test the compatibility, ASAP. The good news is that the mounting system is modular, which means it’s separate from the Slide main unit itself. This means we are going to deploy a large field test of approx. 100 Slide mounts that we’ll send out to backers from Feb 19th onwards. The objective is to quickly verify that you are able to place the Slide mount on your system without trouble. Most of you have completed the Backerkit survey, and many of you submitted photos of your curtain systems. We’re using that to make an initial selection of ‘outlying’/untested types of curtain systems. 

    Timeline 

    As those who regularly read the updates know, we are always careful when it comes to communicating production/shipping timelines, simply because it’s difficult to accurately estimate how much time it takes to complete engineering something new. Internally, we review and adjust our planning every month, but we also know it’s always subject to change. Towards you as backers, instead of shouting production estimates too often, we focus on talking about the underlying work and progress, which ultimately determines how fast we can move forward. 

    But as always, it’s important to stick to transparency, so we’re including the latest copy of our internal planning doc below. It’s updated to reflect our recent meetings with our production partners, and incorporates the to-do’s based on the beta round. In summary, here’s what it says: 

    • This month, we’re focusing on pre-DFM optimization of the internal mechanical build, we continue iterating on the servo-less design, and will send out our test mounts to backers to verify compatibility.
    • In March, our internal build will go through several revisions to incorporate optimizations for (a.o.) the internal wiring. The servo-less design will also be integrated into the main build. This is basically when we dot the I’s and cross the T’s.
    • By April, our production partner will take over with DFM (Design-for-Manufacturing). Near the end of this month, we’ll have a fully finalized Slide that in every respect will look and function the same as the unit you’re getting.
    • In May, DFM will transition into tooling (first the internal and moving parts, later the external parts like the casing). In parallel, the first mass-series of PCBs are produced and shipped to the assembly location.
    • By June everything finally comes together as the T0 and T1 series come off the production line and we can commence shipping. 

     

    Click for hi-res
    Click for hi-res

    Obviously, we know it sucks that there’s still a few months of waiting before Slide rolls of the production line in volumes. But compared to two months ago, the beta test verified to us that except for the servo replacement, all other internal components are now at the ‘optimization’ rather than ‘engineering’ stage. That’s convenient, because it’s much easier to estimate how long it takes to prepare parts for production than to estimate how long it takes to engineer (invent) parts from scratch. This means, in a nutshell, that this timeline comes with a much higher degree of certainty than before. :-) 

    ‘One more thing’ 

    When we redesigned Slide on both the inside and the outside last year, we built it around an aluminum extrusion frame. Over these past few months of engineering, all the reasons to choose for aluminum disappeared one by one. In its current version, we’ve managed to achieve the same structural integrity using an aluminum L-profile, without the weight of a full aluminum chassis. Opting for two separate side panels also further simplifies product assembly, which is a major asset. 

    At the same time, people that saw Slide in real life often remarked that the design looked cool – but also a bit cold, boring and uninspiring. It’s 2018, and smart home tech should fit in your home – even if it’s always hidden behind your curtain. ;-) So, we figured: take a shift in the mechanical design, add aesthetic consideration, and turn a necessity into a virtue (‘van de nood een deugd maken’, as we like to say in Dutch). Here’s a sneak peek of what’s coming your way:  


    In conclusion  

    So – that’s a wrap! Per usual, we hope you find this update informative, transparent and ideally, fun to read as well. I started off writing I was genuinely excited, and hopefully you’ve caught on some of that excitement as well. We’re always looking forward to hearing your thoughts, so let us know what you think, as well as any questions you might have. Also let us know if this degree of detail is valuable – because it does take time to write it down. ;-) In any case – have a good week and our next update is out in three weeks on Monday February 26th!  

    Cheers from freezing Amsterdam,  

    Thijs & Kaj

    P.S. - We have a little bit of backlog with our emails - if you're waiting for a response, please bear with us for a few more days, we're looking to answer all messages by the end of the week. Thank you! 

  • awesome. Thanks for the update!
  • I like the new design; much better than the beta version. It looks a bit like a white Sonos :)

    @Julian: I have discussed with Kaj why your Slide may or may not be detected. At the end of this week you'll probably receive an "Over the air" (OTA) software update, as stated in their update. If by next week your Slide still doesn't get detected, please contact me so we can investigate further. I can make a javascript file that scans all devices on the network and we might be able to see more then (you'd have to install NodeJS on a PC in the same network though)
  • @jorden
    Ok, will wait for the update, hope that resolves the issue! 
    • "There's a weird, subtle ticking noise, also when you don't use it" 
    It would be good to know how 'subtle' this is and if they are going to do something about it. From their comments it doesn't feel like they have a solution for it yet.
    Has this subtle ticking noise been eliminated with the recent update of slide? Because that's the only reason I havent bought them yet.
  • Jesper said:
    • "There's a weird, subtle ticking noise, also when you don't use it" 
    It would be good to know how 'subtle' this is and if they are going to do something about it. From their comments it doesn't feel like they have a solution for it yet.
    Has this subtle ticking noise been eliminated with the recent update of slide? Because that's the only reason I havent bought them yet.
    I think I still heard it yesterday, but not sure. It's really not something that you notice easily. It has to be really quiet before you can hear it.
    I think that, because they got the "Servo out" as they described in their last mail, the problem will be 100% solved.
  • @jorden
    My Slide got updated, I tried to pair it with Homey but this still does not work, too bad. The Slide-app on Homey crashed so I unstalled and re-installed it. Now it does not crash but gives a time-out or invalid session after some time. 
  • @jorden
    Any update regarding the slide app? I tried a couple of times now but still no success.
  • Julian said:
    @jorden
    Any update regarding the slide app? I tried a couple of times now but still no success.
    I'll PM you
Sign In or Register to comment.